Study indicates ethnic hate is contagious
Why do ethnic conflicts in some parts of the world flare up so easily and
spread so fast? Is ethnic hate and intolerance contagious? Researchers from
the Czech Republic and Slovakia joined forces to try to find the answers to
some of those questions and arrived at some surprising conclusions. I spoke
to Associate Professor Michal Bauer, an expert on experimental and
behavioral economics at CERGE-EI, who is one of the authors of the study,
and began by asking him what motivated the research in this field.
“The original motivation for thinking about this question is the
observation that a lot of real-life conflicts often arise out of nothing.
Different groups live next to each other for a long time and then something
snaps, something occurs and inter-community hostilities spread. So what we
tried to do was that in a controlled experimental environment we tried to
measure how easy it is to change individuals’ hostile or destructive
behaviour towards an ethic minority.”
How did you do that? Who did you work with and what kind of experiment was
it?
“The experiment took place in Eastern Slovakia, in around 15 localities,
typically in villages or smaller towns in which the Roma minority and
Slovak majority live together, and the participants were adolescents from
local schools.”
And how did you measure the degree of ethnic hostility?
“We used modern techniques of experimental economics. If one wanted to
measure hostile behavior or attitudes by asking questions in a survey one
would very likely not get a truthful answer, so we used incentivized tasks
in which the participants make choices which impact their own rewards and
the rewards of somebody else. We used a game in which a contestant receives
rewards or money and he or she is asked to make a decision whether to
sacrifice one’s own reward in order to harm the other person even more.
When people pay to harm someone else, we can measure individual willingness
to harm somebody, and in this case destroying someone else’s resources is
really nasty, because I need to pay in order to harm somebody.”
And teenagers influenced each other in making these decisions?
“That’s right. What we tried to look at were essentially two things. We
tried to measure the extent of discrimination towards the Roma as compared
to an anonymous person from the Slovak group by providing information about
who is the experimental counterpart, who is the person that will get harmed
by the decision. And by looking at the differences between these different
types of partners we can measure discrimination. Now to get to the main
question about how one can identify the influence of peers, the
participants made choices in groups of three individuals and they made
choices sequentially, so some of the subjects were making decisions after
observing that somebody from their own group was behaving
non-destructively, while others were making decisions after observing that
somebody from their own group was being hostile to the other person. And
the question was to what extent the behavior of my peers was going to
affect my own behavior. That’s the crucial measure we used to identify
the effect of spreading of hostile behavior – i.e. to what extent I’m
going to copy, or conform to what my classmates are doing.”
Are individuals so vulnerable then, to peer-influence?
“Yes, it turns out that peers matter a lot. For instance, the prevalence
of hostile behavior, if I see that my class mate is non-aggressive is
around 17 percent, while the prevalence of destruction increases to more
than 70 percent, if I am acting after observing a destructive classmate. So
peers have a very strong influence, especially if the decision impacts a
member of the Roma minority, then the extent of conformism is more than
twice as large.”
Is this something deeply inherent? Is this how bullying starts?
“That’s a very good question and it is hard to say at this moment from
just this particular study. We would need more data about how generalizable
this is. There is some indication from a follow-up study we conducted in
the same setting that looks at the social appropriateness of harming
somebody, essentially how people perceive social norms and what we see is
that the social norm regulating hostile behavior towards my own group is
relatively stable. People pretty much always –independently of what their
classmates are doing – consider destructive behavior as an act that is
not socially desirable, while this perception is more fragile when it comes
to hostile behavior towards the Roma.”
So, if I understand you correctly, this is translatable –or applicable
–to conflicts in other countries as well?
“I think it is still an open question since the data that we have are
from one study, at the same time there are indications from other studies
that would point in this direction. Let me give you one example. If we look
at the situation in the UK after the Brexit vote, one interesting
observation in crime data is that the prevalence of hate crime increased by
around 50 percent after this aggressive campaign against immigrants. This
again suggests that it is relatively easy to change social norms of
behavior against individuals from different groups.”
You worked with teenagers, but what you are saying now would suggest that
the same applies to different age groups as well …
“Yes, we studied teenagers. Again, we do not have hard data to test this,
but it would be very interesting to see if this applies to adults as well.
From other types of studies it seems that there are some social spillovers;
that hostility is easy to spread even among adults.”
Is that what populist politicians bank on, when they lead anti-migrant or
anti-ethnic campaigns?
“Yes, that assumption is very consistent with what we find –if
politicians are aware of the social inflammability of being aggressive
towards ethnic outgroups then that may explain why certain types of
politicians – in literature they are called “entrepreneurs of hatred”
- often choose to have aggressive political campaigns towards migrants or
other minority groups.”
So would this research also explain the wave of anti-migrant sentiments in
some parts of Europe today?
“I think a lot of people in Europe are worried by politicians playing
this card –focusing on the fear of migrants – worried that it might be
relatively easy to change people’s attitude towards migrants. I earlier
mentioned this example –the increased prevalence of hate crime following
the aggressive campaigns in favour of Brexit that focused on migrants. That
is consistent with the idea that people’s attitude towards migrants may
be easily changed. I think one of the exciting questions for future
research would be to look at whether the contagious nature of the hostility
that we see towards the Roma –whether the same holds for other groups,
for instance migrating groups, maybe whether it interacts with previous
experience with those groups, meaning whether the tendency to follow
others’ aggressive behavior can be mitigated by previous contact and
knowledge of those groups.”
Did you also consider how to counterbalance or stifle this aggression? I
saw in one of your articles an emphasis on the strict punishment of hate
crimes. If individuals see hate crimes swiftly punished would they not be
less inclined to violence themselves?
“One implication of what we find is that essentially the social cost of
being hostile to hate crimes against people of a different ethnicity is
considerable, because they can cause the quick spread of destruction. This
implies that it may be optimal for societies to have hate crime laws that
punish more severely ethnically or religiously motivated hate crimes. What
we have studied is a stylized experiment, but it implies that the social
costs of this type of anti-social behavior are particularly large. Another
implication is that essentially early diagnosis appears to be very
important –it seems important to focus on the first signs of inter-ethnic
tensions because they may easily spread among others and it may be too late
to start fighting them at a later stage.”
Your study was the first of its kind on the subject, was it not?
“Our study essentially offers a methodology how to study the spread of
hostilities in a controlled environment. There have been a lot of great
studies that looked at whether people discriminate in normal circumstances
when they make choices on their own and whether discrimination exists in
different societies against different groups – what this study is
offering is an experimental method focusing on the question, not just
whether discrimination exists in normal circumstances, but also how easy it
is to trigger discrimination in a social environment depending on what
others are doing from my own group.”
Is this not a strange area of study for economists?
“I think economists are increasingly open to thoughts from other fields
and they try to offer some of their tools to systematically test the
importance of some of the concepts that have been developed by other social
sciences and I think it is a fruitful exchange. But you are certainly right
that this is not a standard economic topic –it is a topic at the
intersection of fields.”
What about other triggers or roots of ethnic hatred – will you be
investigating them as well? Do you plan to take this further?
“We are thinking about other directions. One potentially interesting
question could be related to whether people are inclined to punish
collectively – if somebody does something bad to somebody else whether
people hold responsible only the given individual or also all those who
look similarly as the perpetrator –ie. belong in a given group. Another
interesting question relating to triggers could be whether economic
conditions influence people’s willingness to act anti-socially, stress
factors. A lot of conflicts seem to happen after economic crises or
negative income shocks and the question is whether these economic shocks
have certain psychological effects, either by creating stress or through
some other channels that make people more likely to act anti-socially. I
think these are all exciting questions and hopefully we’ll get some
answers in the years to come.”
 |
 Related articles | | Date | Title | Feature |
| 01.08.2017 | Romany rapper Radek Banga to receive František Kriegel Award for civic
courage | News |
| 08.12.2016 | Project aimed at fighting hate crime acquires fresh urgency in light of
migrant crisis | News |
| 14.11.2016 | Romany soccer team face hatred more or less all the time, says FC Roma
co-director Tomáš Bojar | News |
| 08.02.2016 | Far-right focus on migrants taking heat of Roma at least for now, says
Czechs Against Czechs maker Tomáš Kratochvíl | News |
| 28.10.2015 | A foreign influence | News |
| 08.09.2014 | Lukáš Houdek, a photographer, writer and curator tackling prejudices
head-on | News |
| 12.09.2013 | Brochures for schools to help combat racial prejudice and extremism | News |
| 23.08.2013 | Extremists relying increasingly on internet to whip up anti-Roma sentiments | News |
| 31.07.2013 | Mainstream antipathy to Roma bigger threat than far right, warms Czech
intelligence | News |
| 29.07.2013 | Lukáš Houdek, a photographer, writer and curator tackling prejudices
head-on | News |
| 04.07.2013 | České Budějovice braces for more violence as new anti-Roma demo called | News |
| 01.07.2013 | Anti-Roma riots in České Budějovice point to extremist trend | News |
| 30.05.2013 | Demonstration in Duchcov sparks fears of renewed violence | News |
| 29.05.2013 | Survey indicates strong anti-Roma sentiment among Czech children | News |
| 18.04.2013 | Is the Czech media helping give Romanies a bad name? | News |
| 08.04.2013 | AI launches Europe-wide campaign to end discrimination against Roma | News |
| 30.11.2012 | Education ministry planning effective action against discrimination
of Romanies in the education system | News |
| 13.11.2012 | Students highlight segregation in education during Roma Week | News |
| 27.09.2012 | Jakub Polák, doyen of the Czech anarchist scene, dies aged 60 | News |
| 05.06.2012 | Students in survey perceive Roma to be biggest ‘problem’ | News |
| 24.05.2012 | Roma attack on teen, that brought thousands into the streets, never
happened | News |
| 21.03.2012 | Concert, screening at Prague’s Lucerna to mark day against racism | News |
| 07.03.2012 | Study warns of possible new attacks against Roma as neo-Nazi movement gains
traction | News |
| 11.01.2012 | Extremist lawyer claims judicial expert biased because of Jewish background | News |
| 03.10.2011 | Roma rights advocate Gwendolyn Albert on anti-Romany rallies, poverty and
the government’s strategy in combating social exclusion | News |
| 23.09.2011 | Ethnic tensions rack north Bohemian town of Varnsdorf | News |
| 19.09.2011 | Prime and Labor Minister highlight importance of social reform in solving
Šluknov district’s racial tensions | News |
| 12.09.2011 | Police intervene in attack of far-right extremists and locals against
Romany housing unit in Varnsdorf | News |
| 05.09.2011 | Extremist groups aim to benefit from social unrest in North Bohemia | News |
| 29.04.2011 | Brno braces itself for Sunday’s neo-Nazi march | News |
| 09.11.2010 | Czech human rights groups say no action taken to end schools discrimination
against Roma three years after landmark ruling | News |
| 21.10.2010 | Czech president surprised by long terms for neo-Nazis convicted over
petrol-bomb attack on Romany home | News |
| 20.10.2010 | Court hands tough sentences to Romany family’s attackers | News |
| 06.10.2010 | State attorney demands exemplary sentences for neo-Nazis in arson-attack case | News |
| 29.06.2010 | Suspected arsonist caught on tape praising ‘dudes’ who shot Hungarian Roma | News |
| 11.05.2010 | Trial of four accused of racially-motivated attempted murder begins | News |
| 20.04.2010 | Popular Czech children’s book under fiver over racist undertones | News |
| 06.04.2010 | Police investigate latest attack against Romanies | News |
| 30.03.2010 | 85,000 join Facebook campaign against voluntary Romani lessons in schools | News |
| 16.03.2010 | Police mobilised to investigate Ostrava arson attack on Roma family | News |
| 10.02.2010 | Police to form new riot squads to combat growing extremism | News |
| 13.01.2010 | Amnesty International: discrimination of Romany children persists in Czech schools | News |
| 10.12.2009 | Report suggests Czech Roma suffer more discrimination than any other minority in EU | News |
| 05.12.2009 | Police arrest man over racist publication | News |
| 03.12.2009 | Child victim of racist firebomb attack released from hospital after miracle recovery | News |
| 10.11.2009 | TV program to spotlight ‘Roma-phobia’ | News |
| 19.10.2009 | Women against Racism protest Saturday 24 October in Prague | News |
| 02.09.2009 | NGOs call for action in the face of persisting discrimination of Romany children in schools | News |
| 20.07.2009 | Czech heavy metal singer accused of racism over latest album | News |
| 23.06.2009 | Jekhetane Roma (UK) calls on Czech PM Fischer to address the situation of
Roma in the Czech Republic | News |
| 15.06.2009 | Police clamp down on neo-Nazi protesters around the country | News |
| 04.06.2009 | Top Czech Radio Roma reporter applies for asylum in Canada | News |
| 21.05.2009 | Czech Television put on the spot over anti-Roma election clips | News |
| 23.04.2009 | Romanies call for nation-wide rallies to condemn racist attacks on their community | News |
| 21.04.2009 | Will the government’s proposals to stamp out extremism work? | News |
| 21.04.2009 | Romanies calling on government for protection in the wake of vicious arson attack | News |
| 16.09.2008 | Deputy PM's Roma plan raises eyebrows | News |
| 23.04.2008 | Senator accused of defamation retains political immunity | News |
| 22.04.2008 | The Czech Republic and the rise of social exclusion | News |
| 08.04.2008 | Exhibition of 30 racist murders since 1989 marks International Romani Day | News |
| 14.01.2008 | Čunek in trouble again after suggesting Roma families perpetuate social exclusion | News |
| 14.11.2007 | Landmark ruling finds Czech state guilty of violating rights of Roma school children | News |
| 11.07.2007 | Senator in hot water after secret recording captures racist remarks | News |
| 10.04.2007 | Deputy PM facing mounting pressure to step down | News |
| 08.04.2007 | Are the Deputy Prime Minister's offensive remarks about the Roma influencing ordinary citizens? | News |
| 03.04.2007 | International Roma Day celebrations underway in Prague | News |
| 02.04.2007 | Deputy PM Cunek in hot water yet again after comments about Roma | News |
| 12.01.2007 | Citizens initiative seeks anti-discrimination law | News |
| 30.11.2006 | European monitoring centre says more effort is needed to integrate Romany minority | News |
| 03.11.2006 | Vsetin mayor at centre of race storm after evicting Romanies from centre | News |
| 23.03.2005 | 'Wired' Czech Romani women win racial discrimination cases | News |
| 13.12.2004 | Czech Roma discriminated by UK authorities, say Law Lords | News |
| 11.12.2004 | A 'joke' gone too far? | News |
| 02.12.2004 | Government approves anti-discrimination bill | News |
| 20.05.2004 | Police treating attack on Romany family as racially motivated | News |
| 12.03.2004 | Youth crushed by train while attacking Romanies - press | News |
| 08.01.2004 | Light sentences for racist attack come under fire | News |
| 01.10.2003 | Tolerance 2003 campaign aims at fighting racism | News |
| 22.09.2003 | Foreign Ministry to host seminar on discrimination | News |
| 19.08.2003 | Klara Vesela-Samkova: I won't give up battle for Constitutional Court | News |
| 29.03.2002 | Skinhead gets 13 years for murder of Romany man | News |
| 21.02.2002 | Man gets two years for attack on Roma family | News |
| 16.02.2002 | "Poem" circulating about racially-motivated murder | News |
| 14.02.2002 | Counseling for Roma advisors | News |
| 11.02.2002 | Czech Roma want Council on Roma Affairs dissolved | News |
| 06.02.2002 | Five convicted for petrol bomb attack on Roma families | News |
| 23.12.2000 | Court rules anti-Roma attack not racially motivated | News |
| 26.02.2000 | News | News |
| 26.02.2000 | News | News |
| 26.02.2000 | News | News |
| 26.02.2000 | Racially-Motivated Crime | Racism |
| 26.02.2000 | Usti nad Labem / Maticni Street | News about Roma life |
| 26.02.2000 | Photos | Photos |
| 26.02.2000 | Opinion shows that Czechs do not believe wall in Usti nad Labem is a racial issue | News |
| 26.02.2000 | One year since a murder of Sudanese student Hassan Elamin Abdelradi | Racism and Discrimination |
| 26.02.2000 | Czech Roma in the News | Roma in Society |
| 01.09.1999 | Twelve arrested after attack on Roma community in South Moravia | News |
| 20.08.1999 | Court reopens Roma case | News |
| 19.08.1999 | Growing Extremism | News |
| 16.08.1999 | Roma race trial continues | News |
| 11.08.1999 | American Daily labels Czechs as Racist | News |
| 10.08.1999 | Will the United Kingdom introduce visa restrictions for Czech citizens? | News |
| 09.08.1999 | President Havel on Interethnic Relations | News |
| 16.06.1999 | Rights Group to Sue Ministry | News |
| 26.05.1999 | Opinion shows that Czechs do not believe wall in Usti nad Labem is a racial issue | News |
| Fotografie | Fotografie |
| A Personal Account by Anna Polakova | Personalities |
| 
Also in section "News"
Most popular articles