Česky English Deutsch Francais
Roma rights advocate Gwendolyn Albert on anti-Romany rallies, poverty and the government’s strategy in combating social exclusion
03-10-2011 - Jan Richter
The Czech Republic recently saw an outbreak of tensions between the country’s Romany minority and parts of the majority population. People in the isolated northern Bohemian region of Šluknov began holding anti-Romany rallies to protest a growing crime rate in the region; the government reacted by sending in the police but also by adopting a plan to tackle the issue of Romany exclusion and impoverishment. To discuss these and other issues, Radio Prague spoke to Gwendolyn Albert who for the past 15 years has been working with the Romany advocacy group, Romea.

What exactly is happening in northern Bohemia? Is the conflict primarily ethnic or social? How would you describe it in terms people abroad understand?

“One of the basic problems in that area is that it has been neglected in terms of economic development for the past 20 years. You have a large number of people who are unemployed and they don’t see a future for themselves. This is probable the key to the problem.

“What’s new about these events is that they involve local people of all ages who bring their children out to the square to sing the national anthem and then yell, ‘let’s go get them’, and march on parts of town that are easily identifiable as the Roma ghetto.

“So this is a combination of several factors including the fact that Romany people live in segregated conditions in most of the country. Over the past 20 years it’s become more and more of a petit apartheid situation that has made it easier to use them as a scapegoat for your own frustration, to go and target them.”

What is the role of the media and the language they use? The Economist noted the similarities between how the language of the politicians and the media and that of the Third Reich – do you agree?

Gwendolyn Albert “I think the media wants to increase readership, and they know that if they describe things as dramatically as possible, the number of people following them will increase. And so by unnecessarily mentioning the ethnicities of people involved in criminal incidents, that’s one way to do it.

“The other problem is that since about 2006, we have seen in the Czech society an ever-rightward push in the general discourse. It’s normal to use the term ‘nepřizpůsobivý’, or ‘inadaptable’, which comes from the Nazi era. This is a way of referring to the Roma without referring to the Roma as it doesn’t involve ethnic designation. That’s standard use now in everyone’s discourse; the Czech News Agency puts out press releases without quotation marks around that term.

“So this is a real challenge for the media: if this is the language the society is speaking, what can the media do? How can the media make sure they are reporting on what is taking place but not inflate the tensions. This is where we see the irresponsibility of many on-line venues.

“Also, the point of view of the Romany people is almost never represented, and that’s a real problem. They are the mute, silent scapegoats but they have complaints of their own in these places. It’s a very sad situation when you have Romany civil rights leaders who think that what they need to do is to be constantly distancing themselves from crimes that are artificially blown up by the media.”

Isn’t this problem to a large extent caused by the fact that their potential leaders either distance themselves from the community as such, or just don’t live there? The media often cannot find anyone to talk to about what the community really wants…

“This is a depiction of the re-imposition of a society stratified by class in the Czech Republic during the course of the introduction of market economy. You have people who live in great poverty, and you have people who managed to succeed in the competition they have been faced with. It’s true it’s very rare for people who made it into university or able to function on a higher level to return to the communities where people are worst off and assist them.

“I personally know many people who do this in the Roma community in the Czech Republic and who try to get allies for this. But the biggest problem is that the numbers of the Roma are very small, and when you take the fraction of the Romany people capable of being good advocates using the legal system and the tools of democracy, that’s an even smaller fraction.

The Czech government a couple of weeks ago adopted a four-year strategy to tackle the issue, and one that includes addressing the phenomenon of placing Romany children in special schools. What do you think of the government’s approach to the problem?

“Having watched Czech governments for the last 15 years, especially their performance at international bodies, I’m very cynical. My view is that what they are very good at is developing strategies that look very good paper, and promising – whether it’s to the OSCE, to the UN or the Council of Europe – that change is just around the corner – and shifting the blame. This is what’s maybe the most irritating, when you hear the government say it has no power to address things.

“There is a lot of money available from the European social and structural funds which, if properly designed, could alleviate the poverty that exists in this country.

“Market processes are being allowed to run because they fall into the category of market behaviour and so they are given this kind of untouchable status. So you have these people ripping off the state, these landlords at these residential hotels who charge per person, not per square metre, and who are capable of charging large families living in very small rooms a rent that even in Prague would get them more spacious and dignified accommodation. But nobody is sanctioning this behaviour.

“And there are all kinds of other machinations that are going on, like the development of commercial loan services which are loaning to the poor on very high interest rates. This is has nothing to do with Roma or non-Roma; this is simply about policy at a local level the government could regulate more.”

Do you see any risk of these problems being exploited politically as they are in Hungary, for example? Some people in the Czech Republic, including President Václav Klaus, have begun emphasizing national values; they talk the need of traditional, conservative values and dismiss multiculturalism. How serious you think this threat is?

“In the future, I think what will be important to follow and to fight against is exactly the development of a party similar to [Hungary’s extremist] Jobbik party or a Le Pen figure.

“I unfortunately think that what is happening with the very controversial figure at the Czech Education Ministry, Mr Bátora, is part of a process that’s testing what the Czech society will put up with. When President Klaus leaves in 2013, it’s entirely possible that he will try to become exactly such a figure.

Václav Klaus “I think this is a real possibility, and I think the mainstream parties should be very careful that they define themselves and keep their members with them. Depending on how long it takes for the EU-funded solutions to get going here in the Czech Republic, depending on much further into poverty these really depressed areas are allowed to fall, there is a definite chance that Mr Klaus will ride in on a white horse and fill that gap in the political spectrum.”

Related articles
06.06.2018Study indicates ethnic hate is contagiousNews
01.08.2017Romany rapper Radek Banga to receive František Kriegel Award for civic courageNews
08.12.2016Project aimed at fighting hate crime acquires fresh urgency in light of migrant crisisNews
14.11.2016Romany soccer team face hatred more or less all the time, says FC Roma co-director Tomáš BojarNews
09.08.2016Philharmonic offers life chance to deprived Roma childrenNews
08.02.2016Far-right focus on migrants taking heat of Roma at least for now, says Czechs Against Czechs maker Tomáš KratochvílNews
03.09.2015EDUin’s Bob Kartous: inclusive education in the Czech Republic still facing plenty of hurdlesNews
12.02.2015Report paints grim picture on Czech social exclusion, education reform seen as main hopeNews
08.09.2014Lukáš Houdek, a photographer, writer and curator tackling prejudices head-onNews
12.09.2013Brochures for schools to help combat racial prejudice and extremismNews
23.08.2013Extremists relying increasingly on internet to whip up anti-Roma sentimentsNews
31.07.2013Mainstream antipathy to Roma bigger threat than far right, warms Czech intelligenceNews
29.07.2013Lukáš Houdek, a photographer, writer and curator tackling prejudices head-onNews
04.07.2013České Budějovice braces for more violence as new anti-Roma demo calledNews
01.07.2013Anti-Roma riots in České Budějovice point to extremist trendNews
30.05.2013Demonstration in Duchcov sparks fears of renewed violenceNews
29.05.2013Survey indicates strong anti-Roma sentiment among Czech childrenNews
18.04.2013Is the Czech media helping give Romanies a bad name?News
27.09.2012Jakub Polák, doyen of the Czech anarchist scene, dies aged 60News
07.08.2012Romani residents determined to stay in their homes despite eviction noticeNews
05.06.2012Students in survey perceive Roma to be biggest ‘problem’News
24.05.2012Roma attack on teen, that brought thousands into the streets, never happenedNews
21.03.2012Concert, screening at Prague’s Lucerna to mark day against racismNews
07.03.2012Study warns of possible new attacks against Roma as neo-Nazi movement gains tractionNews
11.01.2012Extremist lawyer claims judicial expert biased because of Jewish backgroundNews
23.09.2011Ethnic tensions rack north Bohemian town of VarnsdorfNews
22.09.2011Government adopts strategy on fighting Romany exclusionNews
20.09.2011Čáslav takes tough line with Romany newcomers amidst fears of racial problemsNews
19.09.2011Prime and Labor Minister highlight importance of social reform in solving Šluknov district’s racial tensionsNews
12.09.2011Police intervene in attack of far-right extremists and locals against Romany housing unit in VarnsdorfNews
05.09.2011Extremist groups aim to benefit from social unrest in North BohemiaNews
29.04.2011Brno braces itself for Sunday’s neo-Nazi marchNews
07.03.2011Government’s Roma inclusion agency head Martin Šimáček: most mayors not ready to work hard on integrationNews
16.02.2011Towns want controversial powers to deal with transients and petty criminalsNews
09.11.2010Czech human rights groups say no action taken to end schools discrimination against Roma three years after landmark rulingNews
21.10.2010Czech president surprised by long terms for neo-Nazis convicted over petrol-bomb attack on Romany homeNews
20.10.2010Court hands tough sentences to Romany family’s attackersNews
06.10.2010State attorney demands exemplary sentences for neo-Nazis in arson-attack caseNews
29.06.2010Suspected arsonist caught on tape praising ‘dudes’ who shot Hungarian RomaNews
11.05.2010Trial of four accused of racially-motivated attempted murder beginsNews
20.04.2010Popular Czech children’s book under fiver over racist undertonesNews
06.04.2010Police investigate latest attack against RomaniesNews
30.03.201085,000 join Facebook campaign against voluntary Romani lessons in schoolsNews
16.03.2010Police mobilised to investigate Ostrava arson attack on Roma familyNews
10.02.2010Police to form new riot squads to combat growing extremismNews
22.01.2010Officials outline Czech participation in European Year against Poverty and Social ExclusionNews
13.01.2010Amnesty International: discrimination of Romany children persists in Czech schoolsNews
05.12.2009Police arrest man over racist publicationNews
03.12.2009Child victim of racist firebomb attack released from hospital after miracle recoveryNews
10.11.2009TV program to spotlight ‘Roma-phobia’News
19.10.2009Women against Racism protest Saturday 24 October in PragueNews
20.07.2009Czech heavy metal singer accused of racism over latest albumNews
23.06.2009Jekhetane Roma (UK) calls on Czech PM Fischer to address the situation of Roma in the Czech RepublicNews
15.06.2009Police clamp down on neo-Nazi protesters around the countryNews
04.06.2009Top Czech Radio Roma reporter applies for asylum in CanadaNews
21.05.2009Czech Television put on the spot over anti-Roma election clipsNews
23.04.2009Romanies call for nation-wide rallies to condemn racist attacks on their communityNews
21.04.2009Will the government’s proposals to stamp out extremism work?News
21.04.2009Romanies calling on government for protection in the wake of vicious arson attackNews
08.04.2008Exhibition of 30 racist murders since 1989 marks International Romani DayNews
11.07.2007Senator in hot water after secret recording captures racist remarksNews
08.04.2007Are the Deputy Prime Minister's offensive remarks about the Roma influencing ordinary citizens?News
03.04.2007International Roma Day celebrations underway in PragueNews
02.04.2007Deputy PM Cunek in hot water yet again after comments about RomaNews
30.11.2006European monitoring centre says more effort is needed to integrate Romany minorityNews
20.05.2004Police treating attack on Romany family as racially motivatedNews
12.03.2004Youth crushed by train while attacking Romanies - pressNews
08.01.2004Light sentences for racist attack come under fireNews
01.10.2003Tolerance 2003 campaign aims at fighting racismNews
22.09.2003Foreign Ministry to host seminar on discriminationNews
29.03.2002Skinhead gets 13 years for murder of Romany manNews
21.02.2002Man gets two years for attack on Roma familyNews
16.02.2002"Poem" circulating about racially-motivated murderNews
14.02.2002Counseling for Roma advisorsNews
11.02.2002Czech Roma want Council on Roma Affairs dissolvedNews
06.02.2002Five convicted for petrol bomb attack on Roma familiesNews
23.12.2000Court rules anti-Roma attack not racially motivatedNews
26.02.2000Opinion shows that Czechs do not believe wall in Usti nad Labem is a racial issueNews
26.02.2000One year since a murder of Sudanese student Hassan Elamin AbdelradiRacism and Discrimination
26.02.2000Czech Roma in the NewsRoma in Society
26.02.2000Racially-Motivated CrimeRacism
26.02.2000Usti nad Labem / Maticni StreetNews about Roma life
01.09.1999Twelve arrested after attack on Roma community in South MoraviaNews
20.08.1999Court reopens Roma caseNews
19.08.1999Growing ExtremismNews
16.08.1999Roma race trial continuesNews
26.05.1999Opinion shows that Czechs do not believe wall in Usti nad Labem is a racial issueNews
A Personal Account by Anna PolakovaPersonalities
Format for printing
Send as e-mail

Also in section "News"
31.10.19  Roma children’s choir Chavorenge and members of the Czech Philharmonic to perform in UK
13.09.19  Archaeologists discover graves of Roma persecuted during WWII in Lety camp
02.06.19  Ida Kelarová and her Romany children’s choir Chavorenge
29.05.19  Two Roma activists to receive Charter 77’s František Kriegel Award
07.04.19  Romany music from the Czech Republic
13.03.19  Czech singer Věra Bílá, dubbed the Ella Fitzgerald of Gypsy music, dies days before her comeback tour
21.11.18  Roma social worker from Ostrava listed on BBC 100 Women list
12.10.18  Why are there so few Roma politicians?
17.09.18  Virtuoso pianist Tomáš Kačo: When I tell somebody I’m a Gypsy in the US, they’re excited about it
06.06.18  Study indicates ethnic hate is contagious
Archive of the section

Most popular articles
3153053   26.02.00 Some Basic Information about the Roma Population in the Czech Republic
290319   27.01.05 The 'Devouring': A look at the Romani Holocaust
184516   26.02.00 The History and Origin of the Roma
141463   26.02.02 The Language of the Roma
107706   13.06.00 The History of the Roma Minority in the Czech Republic
105260   26.02.00 The Traditional Family Life of the Czech Roma
103929   02.06.03 The Roma Holocaust
88238    World famous Roma Personalities
88174   21.02.04 Extreme right activists demonstrate for skinhead in jail
74801    Photographs by Romani Children
Copyright © Český rozhlas / Czech Radio, 1997-2020
Vinohradská 12, 120 99 Praha 2, Czech Republic