Česky English Deutsch Francais
Czech Foreign Minister’s comments over Roma expulsion rack up tension between Prague and Paris
30-08-2010 - Chris Johnstone
A very undiplomatic spat has blown up between Prague and Paris. The fuse was lit by Czech Foreign Minister Karel Schwarzenberg who said that France’s ongoing expulsion of Roma, or gypsies, from camps across the country smacked of racism.

Roma women gesture before being expelled from France at Roissy airport, photo: CTK French Prime Minister François Fillon there exhorting French ambassadors to defend the country in the face of foreign criticism of its policy of expelling Roma from makeshift camps in France back to where they came from, Romania. Mr. Fillon declared the policy just and in line with European law.

A few days later, the Czech Republic’s top diplomat, Karel Schwarzenberg, begged to differ. In a newspaper interview, the Czech Republic’s Foreign Minister said it was impossible not to suspect that a racist perspective played a role in the French expulsions and added that they were contrary to the spirit and rules of the 27-strong European Union.

Michael Kocáb The Czech Republic’s representative for human rights and minorities, Michael Kocáb, later weighed into the fray. He pointed out that France in September is holding an international conference on the Roma issue without inviting key countries such as Romania, Bulgaria and the Czech Republic. He said it harked backed to the Munich agreement of 1938, where the fate of Czechoslovakia was decided by Britain, France, Germany and Italy without Czechoslovak participation.

The Czech Republic is currently heading a 12-nation initiative, the Decade for Roma Inclusion, which groups countries from Central and Eastern Europe, the Balkans and Spain– all of which have large Roma populations. As such Prague might have expected an invite to the Paris conference.

Roma are escorted by police officers before being expelled from France at Roissy airport, photo: CTK Mr. Kocáb’s counterpart in France, Fançois Zimeray, hit back saying France should not getting lessons on human rights from a country that was in many respects less advanced in the area.

With relations between Prague and Paris ratcheted up, there were some steps to relieve the tension.

First of all, Foreign Minister Karel Schwarzenberg pointed out that he had not directly branded the French actions as racist but has said this was the impression given to outsiders.

Karel Schwarzenberg Czech Prime Minister Petr Nečas on Sunday also stepped into the debate and put some clear distance between himself and his foreign minister.

“I would be very careful about tough talk about the officials of other states. I personally do not think there is any racism. These Roma are being expelled primarily because they have disturbed the peace and are not abiding by certain rules.”

That may have at least superficially have buried the diplomatic spat for the moment. But Czech Foreign Minister Karel Schwarzenberg is due in France next week for his first official visit since being named to the post this time round. He can expect a frosty reception.

Related articles
06.06.2018Study indicates ethnic hate is contagiousNews
08.12.2016Project aimed at fighting hate crime acquires fresh urgency in light of migrant crisisNews
14.11.2016Romany soccer team face hatred more or less all the time, says FC Roma co-director Tomáš BojarNews
08.02.2016Far-right focus on migrants taking heat of Roma at least for now, says Czechs Against Czechs maker Tomáš KratochvílNews
31.01.2015Paul Polansky and the Lety Roma camp: Part 2News
25.11.2014Social Democrat leadership up in arms over local government coalition with ultra-right partyNews
25.11.2014Political commentator Jiří Pehe: Duchcov coalition could seriously damage the Social DemocratsNews
08.09.2014Lukáš Houdek, a photographer, writer and curator tackling prejudices head-onNews
07.11.2013Intelligence service report: corruption and economic problems are fuelling extremismNews
12.09.2013Brochures for schools to help combat racial prejudice and extremismNews
23.08.2013Extremists relying increasingly on internet to whip up anti-Roma sentimentsNews
31.07.2013Mainstream antipathy to Roma bigger threat than far right, warms Czech intelligenceNews
29.07.2013Lukáš Houdek, a photographer, writer and curator tackling prejudices head-onNews
04.07.2013České Budějovice braces for more violence as new anti-Roma demo calledNews
01.07.2013Anti-Roma riots in České Budějovice point to extremist trendNews
30.05.2013Demonstration in Duchcov sparks fears of renewed violenceNews
29.05.2013Survey indicates strong anti-Roma sentiment among Czech childrenNews
07.06.2012Ombudsman says discrimination of Romany children in Czech education system persistsNews
24.05.2012Roma attack on teen, that brought thousands into the streets, never happenedNews
07.03.2012Study warns of possible new attacks against Roma as neo-Nazi movement gains tractionNews
23.09.2011Ethnic tensions rack north Bohemian town of VarnsdorfNews
19.09.2011Prime and Labor Minister highlight importance of social reform in solving Šluknov district’s racial tensionsNews
12.09.2011Police intervene in attack of far-right extremists and locals against Romany housing unit in VarnsdorfNews
26.07.2011Roma advocacy group suspends police cooperation over neo-Nazi marchesNews
29.04.2011Brno braces itself for Sunday’s neo-Nazi marchNews
09.11.2010Czech human rights groups say no action taken to end schools discrimination against Roma three years after landmark rulingNews
21.10.2010Czech president surprised by long terms for neo-Nazis convicted over petrol-bomb attack on Romany homeNews
20.10.2010Court hands tough sentences to Romany family’s attackersNews
06.10.2010State attorney demands exemplary sentences for neo-Nazis in arson-attack caseNews
16.09.2010PM Nečas embroiled in row over Romany repatriationsNews
11.09.2010Key witness in arson case refuses to give evidenceNews
10.09.2010Schwarzenberg: French likely to take more sensitive approach after furore over Roma expulsionsNews
07.09.2010Prague and Paris seek to mend strained relationsNews
07.09.2010Charity concert „For Natálka“News
29.08.2010Prime Minister says ‘racist’ comments of Foreign Minister were rashNews
28.08.2010Foreign Minister says French expulsions appear racistNews
29.06.2010Suspected arsonist caught on tape praising ‘dudes’ who shot Hungarian RomaNews
27.05.2010Vítkov trial expert describes Natálka’s horrific injuriesNews
25.05.2010Four accused of firebomb attack on Romany home not insane, psychiatrist tells courtNews
11.05.2010Trial of four accused of racially-motivated attempted murder beginsNews
20.04.2010Popular Czech children’s book under fiver over racist undertonesNews
19.04.2010Ex-minister Michael Kocáb returns as commissioner for human rightsNews
06.04.2010Police investigate latest attack against RomaniesNews
16.03.2010Police mobilised to investigate Ostrava arson attack on Roma familyNews
22.12.2009Cabinet approves long-term strategy for Romany integrationNews
21.12.2009Cabinet approves long-term strategy for Romany integrationNews
03.12.2009Child victim of racist firebomb attack released from hospital after miracle recoveryNews
24.11.2009PM expresses regret over Roma sterilization but activists say practice continuesNews
07.09.2009Romani civic association endorses Chomutov mayor for re-electionNews
02.09.2009NGOs call for action in the face of persisting discrimination of Romany children in schoolsNews
17.08.2009Czech police may arrest extremist leaders over Vítkov firebomb attack, says representative of affected familyNews
15.08.2009Four charged with attempted murder over attack on Roma familyNews
14.08.2009Four people charged with attempted murder in arson attackNews
13.08.2009Twelve arrested over attack on Romany family’s homeNews
21.07.2009Czech-Romany relations hit low point, says government reportNews
20.07.2009Czech heavy metal singer accused of racism over latest albumNews
10.06.2009Several charged after police mount biggest operation against Czech neo-NazisNews
04.06.2009Top Czech Radio Roma reporter applies for asylum in CanadaNews
05.05.2009Czech government unveils strategy to combat rise in far-right extremismNews
04.05.2009Hundreds of Romanies protest against extremism at nation-wide ralliesNews
26.02.2009Chomutov benefit seizures provokes new row over Romany integrationNews
14.04.2008Petr Torák: the Roma refugee who became a British policemanNews
24.07.2007Will the state compensate women sterilized against their will?News
28.03.2007Nightclub operator fined for refusing to serve RomaNews
31.08.2006Jas receives three year sentence for brutal attack on Romany coupleNews
20.05.2005Roma student to receive compensation for racially-motivated attackNews
Format for printing
Send as e-mail

Also in section "News"
31.10.19  Roma children’s choir Chavorenge and members of the Czech Philharmonic to perform in UK
13.09.19  Archaeologists discover graves of Roma persecuted during WWII in Lety camp
02.06.19  Ida Kelarová and her Romany children’s choir Chavorenge
29.05.19  Two Roma activists to receive Charter 77’s František Kriegel Award
07.04.19  Romany music from the Czech Republic
13.03.19  Czech singer Věra Bílá, dubbed the Ella Fitzgerald of Gypsy music, dies days before her comeback tour
21.11.18  Roma social worker from Ostrava listed on BBC 100 Women list
12.10.18  Why are there so few Roma politicians?
17.09.18  Virtuoso pianist Tomáš Kačo: When I tell somebody I’m a Gypsy in the US, they’re excited about it
06.06.18  Study indicates ethnic hate is contagious
Archive of the section

Most popular articles
3153053   26.02.00 Some Basic Information about the Roma Population in the Czech Republic
290319   27.01.05 The 'Devouring': A look at the Romani Holocaust
184516   26.02.00 The History and Origin of the Roma
141463   26.02.02 The Language of the Roma
107706   13.06.00 The History of the Roma Minority in the Czech Republic
105260   26.02.00 The Traditional Family Life of the Czech Roma
103929   02.06.03 The Roma Holocaust
88238    World famous Roma Personalities
88174   21.02.04 Extreme right activists demonstrate for skinhead in jail
74801    Photographs by Romani Children
Copyright © Český rozhlas / Czech Radio, 1997-2020
Vinohradská 12, 120 99 Praha 2, Czech Republic